Both of my most recent Netgally reads referenced the Sandra Bullock pageant classic MISS CONGENIALITY - what are the odds? Well, actually pretty good since the both focused on a protagonist who is VERY invested in winning a crown. Both main characters are outside the norm for pageant winners - Parker in DDH is a queer boy who is gender flexible and competing against his salty ex. Tylor is a black girl whose mother was murdered just a year ago and is competing against her nemesis who is currently dating her ex. But the similarities end there. Oh wait, they are both planning on going to college in Boston! What is it about going to college in Boston? It was my dream too. All the cool kids are doing it... But I digress.
In DROP DEAD HANDSOME, Parker needs an anecdote for his college essay and decides to compete in his school's Miss Spirit pageant to shine a light on gender roles in the hope that it will make him stand out. He is born for the role - he is willing to take part and loves the dressy-up aspect of the whole thing. Unfortunately, his ex is the front runner, her sister is one of the coordinators and someone is out to make him fail by any means necessary. The mystery of who is trying to sabotage him is what kept me reading, but what ultimately charmed me was his romance with Dean, the hot-nerd who volunteers to be his "escort" for the duration. It was a straight up "I have to work with my crush" trope that was adorable in its paces. They are both interested, but they are both unsure of the other's interest. The only thing that kept it from being a little too cliche is the hysterical commentary of Parker's awesomely supportive (perhaps a bit too supportive) family and the way that the fact that they are gay only upsets the right wing parent group who really just seem more upset that Parker looks fabulous in a gown rather than any shenanigans the boys might be up to in their private lives. The whole thing ends delightfully, no one dies, and true love wins out. I've never been a pageant girl (MISS CONGENIALITY notwithstanding) so the world wasn't super compelling to me, but Hubbard is a very funny writer who is locked in to the teenage romance world in a way that feels true and kept me engaged.
I like a tidy ending and nothing in TYLOR WHITLOCK JUST WON'T DIE is tidy. This is the bloodiest book I have read in forever and I sometimes read Steven King! I mean, seriously, I had to read this REAL fast because I just let my gaze glance over the seemingly never-ending series of murders of Tylor. But first, the set-up. Last year on Valentine's Day, Ty's mom was murdered in her home by a man who appeared to be a former lover who extracted her heart (oh, that's Chekov's heart, it comes up again later) and Tylor and her best friend discovered the body. The murderer was shot by the police before he could confess and so much mystery remains.
So it is Valentines Day again (and again and again) and Tylor gets murdered and Groundhog Days herself back to relive it when she wakes up dead after being killed. So here's the thing. There are several really good books in here. There is her desire to be crowned Miss Sweetheart and defeating her nemesis, there is her blog where she roasts her exes and boys in general, there is her reputation of being "too much" and a slut, there is her longing to leave her small town (for obvious reasons), there is her dawning realization that she might be falling for her best friend Nate (who is also caught in this loop), and there is, of course, her searching for answers about her mother's dealt. Combine that with so many grisly murders (mitigated, but not by much) by the fact that she generally comes back the next (or same) day and I was overwhelmed.
The writing is very good, I feel like I really got to know Tylor and Nate, and their transition from besties to sweethearts was well done. But there are so many fakeouts, both in the romance and the murders, that my head was spinning from trying to keep it all straight. And it wraps up...okay... but its messy. And not just the bloodstains. There are a lot of kids who love horror and I think they will really like this, but it was not the book for me.
Thanks to Netgalley for the digital arcs!


No comments:
Post a Comment